All Topics
biology-sl | ib
Responsive Image
2. Continuity and Change
3. Interaction and Interdependence
4. Form and Function
Theories of evolution (Darwin, Lamarck)

Topic 2/3

left-arrow
left-arrow
archive-add download share

Your Flashcards are Ready!

15 Flashcards in this deck.

or
NavTopLeftBtn
NavTopRightBtn
3
Still Learning
I know
12

Theories of Evolution: Darwin and Lamarck

Introduction

Evolutionary theory is a cornerstone of modern biology, explaining the diversity of life on Earth. Within the International Baccalaureate (IB) Biology Standard Level (SL) curriculum, understanding the foundational theories of evolution, particularly those proposed by Charles Darwin and Jean-Baptiste Lamarck, is essential. These theories provide insights into how species adapt and diversify over time, forming the basis for studying evolution and speciation under the unit "Unity and Diversity."

Key Concepts

Jean-Baptiste Lamarck's Theory of Evolution

Jean-Baptiste Lamarck, a French naturalist, was one of the earliest scientists to propose a comprehensive theory of evolution. His ideas, formulated in the early 19th century, laid the groundwork for later evolutionary theories despite being eventually overshadowed by Darwinian natural selection.

Lamarck's theory is primarily characterized by two main principles:

  • Use and Disuse: Lamarck proposed that organisms develop or lose traits based on their usage. If an organism frequently uses a particular organ or structure, it becomes more developed, whereas disuse leads to its reduction.
  • Inheritance of Acquired Characteristics: According to Lamarck, traits acquired during an organism's lifetime due to environmental interactions or behaviors can be passed on to its offspring.

**Example:** Lamarck suggested that giraffes developed long necks because ancestral giraffes stretched their necks to reach higher foliage. The continuous stretching would lead to longer necks, which were then inherited by subsequent generations.

While Lamarck's theory was revolutionary for its time, it lacked empirical evidence and failed to explain the mechanisms behind inheritance, leading to its decline in scientific acceptance.

Charles Darwin's Theory of Evolution by Natural Selection

Charles Darwin revolutionized biological sciences with his theory of evolution by natural selection, detailed in his seminal work, "On the Origin of Species" (1859). Darwin's theory provided a robust and evidence-based framework for understanding the diversity and adaptability of life.

Key components of Darwin's theory include:

  • Variation: Individuals within a species exhibit variations in traits. These variations can be subtle or significant and are often heritable.
  • Inheritance: Traits are passed from parents to offspring. Offspring tend to resemble their parents, allowing advantageous traits to accumulate over generations.
  • Overproduction: Most species produce more offspring than can survive due to limitations in resources such as food, space, and shelter.
  • Struggle for Existence: Due to overproduction and limited resources, individuals compete for survival. This competition leads to differential survival and reproduction rates.
  • Natural Selection: Traits that confer a survival or reproductive advantage become more common in the population over time. Conversely, disadvantageous traits may be eliminated.

**Example:** The finches of the Galápagos Islands, studied by Darwin, exhibit variations in beak shapes and sizes. These adaptations allow different finch species to exploit various food sources, reducing competition and enhancing survival.

Darwin's theory emphasized gradual change and adaptation through natural processes, providing a scientific explanation for the complexity and adaptability of life without invoking supernatural mechanisms.

Mechanisms of Evolution

Both Lamarckian and Darwinian theories aim to explain how evolution occurs, albeit through different mechanisms. Understanding these mechanisms is crucial for comprehending evolutionary processes.

  • Lamarckian Mechanism: Evolution is driven by the use and disuse of organs and the inheritance of acquired traits. Environmental changes induce behavioral or physiological changes that are then genetically transmitted.
  • Darwinian Mechanism: Evolution is driven by natural selection acting on heritable variations. Random mutations introduce genetic diversity, and selective pressures determine which traits are advantageous for survival and reproduction.

Modern evolutionary biology recognizes that while Lamarck's ideas were foundational, Darwin's concepts of natural selection, combined with Mendelian genetics, provide a more accurate and comprehensive explanation of evolutionary dynamics.

Genetic Basis of Evolution

Darwin's theory initially lacked a clear understanding of the genetic basis of inheritance. The integration of Gregor Mendel's work on genetics with Darwinian natural selection led to the development of the Modern Synthesis in the early 20th century.

Key aspects include:

  • Genetic Variation: Genetic mutations and recombination during sexual reproduction generate variation within populations. This variation is the raw material upon which natural selection acts.
  • Alleles and Genotypes: Different forms of a gene (alleles) result in variations in traits. The combination of alleles (genotype) influences the organism's phenotype.
  • Population Genetics: Studies the distribution and changes of allele frequencies under the influence of evolutionary processes such as selection, drift, mutation, and migration.

**Equations and Models:**

One fundamental equation in population genetics is the Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium, which provides a mathematical model for studying genetic variation in a population:

p2+2pq+q2=1 p^2 + 2pq + q^2 = 1

Where:

  • p: Frequency of the dominant allele.
  • q: Frequency of the recessive allele.

This equation serves as a null hypothesis, allowing scientists to identify evolutionary forces acting on a population by comparing observed genetic frequencies to expected frequencies.

Speciation

Speciation, the process by which new species arise, is a critical aspect of evolutionary biology. Both Lamarckian and Darwinian frameworks address speciation, with Darwin's theory providing a more detailed explanation.

Types of speciation include:

  • Allopatric Speciation: Occurs when populations become geographically isolated, preventing gene flow. Over time, genetic divergence leads to the emergence of distinct species.
  • Sympatric Speciation: Happens without geographical barriers, often through mechanisms like polyploidy in plants or behavioral changes that lead to reproductive isolation.

**Example:** The formation of new cichlid species in African Great Lakes is a classic example of adaptive radiation and speciation driven by ecological niches.

Darwin's emphasis on natural selection and adaptation provides a robust framework for understanding how speciation occurs in response to environmental pressures and genetic variations.

Modern Developments in Evolutionary Theory

Since Darwin and Lamarck, evolutionary theory has expanded significantly, incorporating insights from genetics, molecular biology, and computational biology.

  • Neutral Theory of Molecular Evolution: Proposed by Motoo Kimura, this theory posits that most evolutionary changes at the molecular level are the result of genetic drift of neutral mutations rather than selective pressures.
  • Epigenetics: Studies heritable changes in gene expression that do not involve alterations to the DNA sequence. While not supporting Lamarckian inheritance directly, epigenetics reveals additional layers of complexity in inheritance.
  • Evolutionary Developmental Biology (Evo-Devo): Explores how changes in developmental processes lead to evolutionary changes in morphology and function.
  • Horizontal Gene Transfer: The movement of genetic material between organisms outside of traditional reproduction, particularly significant in microbial evolution.

These modern perspectives enhance our understanding of evolution, demonstrating that it is a multifaceted process influenced by a variety of genetic and environmental factors.

Evidence Supporting Darwinian Evolution

Several lines of evidence support Darwin's theory of evolution by natural selection:

  • Fossil Record: Documents gradual changes in species over geological time, showing transitions between major groups.
  • Biogeography: The geographical distribution of species supports common ancestry and diversification in response to environmental conditions.
  • Anatomical Homologies: Similar structures in different species indicate common descent. For example, the forelimbs of vertebrates share a common bone structure despite differing functions.
  • Embryology: Similar embryonic stages among different species suggest a common ancestry.
  • Molecular Biology: Genetic similarities among species reflect evolutionary relationships. DNA sequencing reveals how closely related different organisms are at the molecular level.
  • Direct Observation: Instances of natural selection and speciation have been observed in various species, such as antibiotic resistance in bacteria and changes in beak sizes in finches.

Together, these evidences provide a comprehensive support system for the validity of Darwinian evolutionary theory.

Criticisms and Limitations of Lamarckian and Darwinian Theories

While both Lamarckian and Darwinian theories have significantly contributed to our understanding of evolution, they are not without criticisms and limitations.

  • Lamarckian Theory:
    • Weakness in Inheritance: The main criticism is the lack of empirical evidence supporting the inheritance of acquired characteristics. Modern genetics does not support the idea that traits acquired during an organism's lifetime are passed to offspring.
    • Mechanistic Flaws: The mechanisms proposed by Lamarck, such as use and disuse, do not adequately explain how traits are transmitted genetically.
  • Darwinian Theory:
    • Lack of Genetic Mechanism: Initially, Darwin's theory did not incorporate a genetic basis for inheritance, which was later addressed by the Modern Synthesis.
    • Gradualism vs. Punctuated Equilibrium: Darwin advocated for gradual evolutionary changes, but some evidence supports punctuated equilibrium, where species undergo rapid changes in short geological periods.
    • Complex Traits: Explaining the evolution of highly complex structures, such as the eye, remains a challenge, although gradual incremental improvements are widely accepted.

Despite these criticisms, Darwinian natural selection remains the foundational mechanism of evolution, enriched by subsequent scientific advancements.

Applications of Evolutionary Theory

Evolutionary theory has wide-ranging applications across various disciplines, enhancing our understanding and ability to manipulate biological systems.

  • Medicine: Understanding the evolution of pathogens, such as bacteria developing antibiotic resistance, informs treatment strategies and public health policies.
  • Agriculture: Breeding programs utilize principles of natural selection to develop crop varieties with desirable traits like pest resistance and increased yield.
  • Conservation Biology: Evolutionary principles guide conservation efforts by identifying genetically diverse populations and understanding species' adaptability to changing environments.
  • Forensic Science: Evolutionary markers are used in DNA profiling to identify individuals and establish genetic relationships.
  • Biotechnology: Genetic engineering and synthetic biology rely on evolutionary concepts to design organisms with specific functions.

These applications demonstrate the practical significance of evolutionary theory in addressing real-world challenges and advancing scientific knowledge.

The Role of Natural Selection in Evolution

Natural selection is the primary mechanism by which evolution occurs, driving the adaptation of organisms to their environments. Understanding its role is essential for comprehending how species evolve over time.

  • Directional Selection: Favors one extreme phenotype, causing the population's trait distribution to shift in that direction.
  • Stabilizing Selection: Prefers intermediate phenotypes, reducing variation and maintaining the status quo.
  • Disruptive Selection: Favors both extreme phenotypes, potentially leading to speciation.

**Mathematical Representation:** The change in allele frequency due to selection can be modeled using the selection coefficient (s), which quantifies the relative fitness of genotypes.

Δp=pq(wAw)w \Delta p = \frac{p \cdot q \cdot (w_A - \overline{w})}{\overline{w}}

Where:

  • p: Frequency of allele A.
  • q: Frequency of allele a.
  • w_A: Fitness of genotype AA.
  • &overline;w: Average fitness of the population.

This equation illustrates how allele frequencies shift in response to differential reproductive success, driving evolutionary change.

Evolutionary Trees and Phylogenetics

Phylogenetics involves the study of evolutionary relationships among species, often depicted through evolutionary trees or cladograms. These visual representations elucidate common ancestry and divergence.

  • Cladistics: A method of classifying species based on shared derived characteristics, constructing a branching diagram (cladogram) that represents evolutionary pathways.
  • Monophyletic Groups: Groups consisting of a common ancestor and all its descendants, reflecting true evolutionary relationships.
  • Paraphyletic and Polyphyletic Groups: Paraphyletic groups include a common ancestor and some, but not all, descendants. Polyphyletic groups are formed by convergent traits without a common ancestor.

Advancements in molecular biology, particularly DNA sequencing, have refined phylogenetic analyses, providing more accurate reconstructions of evolutionary histories.

Comparison Table

Aspect Lamarck's Theory Darwin's Theory
Main Mechanism Use and disuse of organs; inheritance of acquired characteristics Natural selection acting on heritable variation
Source of Variation Organism's own effort and needs to adapt Genetic mutations and recombination
Role of the Environment Environment induces changes in the organism's traits Environment selects for advantageous traits among existing variations
Inheritance Acquired traits are passed to offspring Only genetically inherited traits are passed to offspring
Adaptation Process Directed by the organism's needs and use of traits Unbiased selection based on differential survival and reproduction
Scientific Acceptance Historically important but largely discredited Widely accepted and supported by extensive evidence

Summary and Key Takeaways

  • Jean-Baptiste Lamarck introduced early evolutionary ideas based on use and inheritance of acquired traits.
  • Charles Darwin's theory of natural selection provides a robust mechanism for evolution, supported by extensive evidence.
  • Modern evolutionary biology integrates genetics, molecular biology, and other fields to explain the complexity of evolutionary processes.
  • Speciation and genetic variation are fundamental concepts underpinning biodiversity.
  • Understanding evolutionary theories is crucial for applications in medicine, agriculture, conservation, and biotechnology.

Coming Soon!

coming soon
Examiner Tip
star

Tips

Use Mnemonics: Remember Darwin's key components with "VIOWS" - Variation, Inheritance, Overproduction, Weakness (Struggle for Existence), and Selection.

Create Concept Maps: Visualize the relationships between Lamarckian and Darwinian theories to better understand their differences and similarities.

Relate to Current Events: Connect evolutionary concepts to recent discoveries, such as antibiotic resistance, to see their real-world applications and enhance retention.

Did You Know
star

Did You Know

1. Lamarck's Influence on Modern Science: Although Lamarckian inheritance is largely discredited, recent studies in epigenetics have revealed that some acquired traits can be passed to offspring through chemical modifications of DNA.

2. Darwin's Voyage: Charles Darwin's five-year voyage on the HMS Beagle was pivotal in shaping his ideas on evolution, providing him with diverse observations from different ecosystems around the world.

3. Evolutionary Speed: Some species, like the peppered moth, have shown rapid evolutionary changes in response to environmental shifts, such as pollution levels, demonstrating the power of natural selection in real-time.

Common Mistakes
star

Common Mistakes

Mistake 1: Believing that individuals can pass acquired traits genetically. Incorrect: "A strong swimmer parent will have offspring who are also strong swimmers because they trained." Correct: "Offspring inherit genetic traits that may influence swimming ability, but training does not directly alter their genetic makeup."

Mistake 2: Thinking that evolution has a specific direction or goal. Incorrect: "Animals evolve to become better suited for survival in a linear fashion." Correct: "Evolution is a response to environmental pressures without a predetermined direction, leading to diverse adaptations."

Mistake 3: Confusing natural selection with artificial selection. Incorrect: "Natural selection is the same as breeders selecting plants or animals for desired traits." Correct: "Natural selection occurs through environmental pressures, whereas artificial selection is driven by human choice."

FAQ

What is the main difference between Lamarck's and Darwin's theories of evolution?
Lamarck's theory emphasizes the inheritance of acquired characteristics through use and disuse, while Darwin's theory centers on natural selection acting on heritable variations.
How did Darwin collect evidence for his theory of natural selection?
During his voyage on the HMS Beagle, Darwin observed diverse species, fossils, and geographic distributions, which provided empirical support for natural selection.
Can acquired traits be inherited according to modern genetics?
Modern genetics generally refutes the inheritance of acquired traits, though epigenetic mechanisms can sometimes influence gene expression in offspring.
What is the Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium?
It is a principle that provides a mathematical model for studying genetic variation in a population, assuming no evolutionary forces are acting upon it.
How does natural selection lead to speciation?
Natural selection can drive speciation by favoring different traits in isolated populations, leading to genetic divergence and the formation of new species.
What role does genetic variation play in evolution?
Genetic variation provides the raw material for evolution, allowing populations to adapt to changing environments through natural selection.
2. Continuity and Change
3. Interaction and Interdependence
4. Form and Function
Download PDF
Get PDF
Download PDF
PDF
Share
Share
Explore
Explore
How would you like to practise?
close